Trading cards
Modern, vintage, and chase singles spanning sports and collectible card games.
Built for collectors
Shaffer Cards
Collect with confidence.
We're building a trusted home for cards and collectibles—where every item is thoughtfully selected, clearly presented, and handled with care.
Collector gradePresented in the light
What we're building
A better home
for the hobby.
Shaffer Cards is being built as a collector-first destination for discovering, buying, and enjoying the pieces that make the hobby personal. We're carefully integrating inventory, pricing, and the storefront before opening the collection.
Storefront integration in progress
Sealed product
Packs, booster boxes, hobby boxes, and special releases for collectors who love the rip.
Graded cards
Authenticated, graded pieces—from approachable favorites to collection centerpieces.
Collectibles
Display-worthy memorabilia, hobby accessories, and other pieces made for collectors.
Tech solutions
Tools and insights designed to help collectors understand the market and make better decisions.
Who we are
Collectors helping
collectors.
We're collectors too. We understand the excitement of the hunt, the questions that come with every purchase, and the pride of finding the right piece for your collection.
Shaffer Cards is here to make the hobby easier to understand and more enjoyable to explore—with honest guidance, useful education, and real help finding what you're looking for.
The hobby is better when every collector feels informed, welcomed, and confident.
Education without pressure
Clear information and practical insights to help you make decisions at your own pace.
Help with the hunt
Whether it's a favorite player, character, set, or centerpiece, we'll help you find the right fit.
Collection pricing help
Understand what your
collection may be worth.
Not sure where to begin? Send us photos of your collection first. We'll review what you have and provide an estimate of the hours—and expected service cost—it will take to price everything out before work begins.
Now starting with small to medium collections
Start with a simple conversation.
Email clear overview photos, the approximate size of the collection, and a little about what you hope to learn to sales@shaffercards.com.
Send photos and details
Share clear overview photos, what you collect, roughly how many items you have, and your location.
Review the estimate
Based on the photos, we'll estimate the number of hours required and the expected cost before any pricing work begins.
Arrange delivery or shipping
Local collections are coordinated in advance. Collections located outside Indiana will need to be shipped to Shaffer Cards.
Get clear pricing guidance
We'll organize the information and provide practical, market-informed value estimates.
Out-of-state collections
Email photos for an estimate These collections must be shipped to Shaffer Cards for the full review. We'll provide shipping instructions after you approve the estimate.
Or email us directly at sales@shaffercards.com
Pricing guidance is based on available market information and is not a formal appraisal.
The Shaffer standard
Every card deserves
a place in the light.
Collecting is personal. Our standard is simple: treat every card, every detail, and every collector with the attention they deserve.
1
Clear detailsKnow exactly what you’re looking at.
2
Collector careEvery card handled thoughtfully.
3
Real connectionReach us directly, collector to collector.
Store information
Online only.
Indiana based.
Shaffer Cards is currently an online-only store based in McCordsville, Indiana, near Indianapolis. We do not have a walk-in retail storefront at this time.
Questions or inquiries
We're here to help.
Have a question about cards, collectibles, collection pricing, or what we're building? Reach out and we'll get back to you.
Email sales@shaffercards.comLocal collection reviews are coordinated in advance.
